Buddy TV is asking that burning question. According to the site:
We’ve put together a showdown with all the new New Moon cast members included. We felt it wouldn’t be fair to include the older cast members or even Taylor Lautner, who had to rewin his role as Jacob Black. Besides, we all know Robert Pattinson would sweep the competition. This is strictly for the newbies. Who’s the best casting choice? Is it the hot new Alex Meraz? Is it the well known Dakota Fanning? Is it the spot-on Graham Greene? Is the the acclaimed Michael Sheen? Who do you think was the best cast member?